Top Picks for Hotels in Montauk: Your Ultimate Accommodation Guide

Everly Hall
2 months ago

Are you in a hurry?

Here is a quick list of hotels in Montauk, selected based on their rating

Name of hotel Accommodation Rating Price, $
Hero Beach Club

8.3 / 10

(82 Reviews)

From 344$
Kenny'S Tipperary Inn

7.8 / 10

(878 Reviews)

From 138$
Gurney'S Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

8.0 / 10

(196 Reviews)

From 372$
Montauk Manor Hotel

8.7 / 10

(1827 Reviews)

From 174$
Montauk Blue Hotel

8.6 / 10

(1217 Reviews)

From 215$

Nestled at the eastern tip of Long Island, Montauk offers more than just its iconic lighthouse and stunning ocean views. It's a paradise for beach lovers, surfers, and travelers looking for a serene getaway. The hotels in Montauk play a pivotal role in making each visit truly memorable, offering accommodations that range from luxurious retreats to cozy beachfront inns, each with its own unique charm and amenities.

Choosing the right hotel in Montauk is essential to experiencing what this seaside town has to offer. Whether you're in the mood for a spa treatment, a gourmet meal, or just a comfortable bed close to the beach, Montauk's hotels cater to every preference and budget. Recommendations for stay vary widely, ensuring there's a perfect spot for every type of traveler, from the solo wanderer seeking solace to families looking for fun-filled adventures.

Insights into Montauk's hotel scene reveal more than just places to stay; they showcase a gateway to the town's rich history and vibrant culture. The accommodations here are often praised for their attentive service, exceptional food, and breathtaking views. As you plan your trip, consider these hotels as more than just a place to rest your head; they are a crucial part of your Montauk experience, promising comfort and convenience amidst the beauty of one of the United States' most cherished coastal destinations.

Table of contents

Hero Beach Club Kenny'S Tipperary Inn Luxury Retreats: The Best Hotels in Montauk for an Opulent Stay Gurney'S Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa Montauk Manor Hotel Family-Friendly Finds: Top Hotels in Montauk for Families Montauk Blue Hotel

View all photos

8.3
Very good
82 Reviews

Hero Beach Club

📍 626 Montauk Highway

From 344$

Hero Beach Club offers a serene escape for families, set against the backdrop of Umbrella Beach's breathtaking views. The hotel's commitment to a tranquil atmosphere makes it a standout for families seeking a peaceful retreat. Rooms and bungalows are designed with simplicity and comfort in mind, accommodating families of various sizes. The expansive outdoor space includes a pool and picnic areas, encouraging outdoor family activities. With Montauk's natural wonders at its doorstep, Hero Beach Club provides a harmonious balance of relaxation and adventure for family travelers.
Check Availability
Add to compare

Luxury Retreats: The Best Hotels in Montauk for an Opulent Stay

Montauk, a gem at the tip of Long Island, is not just a haven for surfers and beach enthusiasts but also a luxury destination for those seeking a lavish getaway. The luxury hotels in Montauk offer an unparalleled level of sophistication and elegance, blending high-end amenities with breathtaking views of the Atlantic Ocean. These establishments are renowned for their exceptional service, exquisite dining options, and serene spa services, providing the perfect setting for a truly indulgent experience. Here, guests can unwind in beautifully designed spaces that reflect Montauk's natural beauty while enjoying personalized services that cater to their every need. Dive into this section to discover the top luxury hotels in Montauk, each promising an unforgettable stay amidst opulence and tranquility.

View all photos

7.8
Very good
878 Reviews

Kenny'S Tipperary Inn

📍 432 West Lake Drive

From 138$

A short drive from Montauk's lighthouse and state parks, Kenny's Tipperary Inn presents an ideal accommodation for families seeking adventure. This hotel warmly welcomes families of all sizes, offering rooms and suites that cater to extended families, with pet-friendly options for those traveling with furry friends. The on-site pool, adorned with a beautiful mural, provides a serene setting for relaxation after a day of exploration. Nearby access to boat rentals and fishing charters, along with the hotel's close proximity to some of Montauk's best beaches, makes Kenny's Tipperary Inn a prime choice for families looking to experience the diverse offerings of Montauk.
Check Availability
Add to compare

View all photos

8
Very good
196 Reviews

Gurney'S Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

📍 290 Old Montauk Highway

From 372$

Touted as a premier luxury destination in Montauk & Seawater Spa sets the benchmark for opulence. Nestled on a pristine stretch of oceanfront, this iconic resort offers guests an exclusive beach experience, complemented by a seawater spa that is the epitome of relaxation and rejuvenation. Each room and suite is meticulously designed to embrace the natural beauty of Montauk, offering panoramic views of the Atlantic Ocean. Guests can indulge in gourmet dining at the resort's renowned restaurants or enjoy a cocktail at one of the ocean-facing bars. With its unparalleled service and luxurious amenities, Gurney's is a beacon of sophistication for travelers seeking the ultimate luxury experience in Montauk.
Check Availability
Add to compare

Family-Friendly Finds: Top Hotels in Montauk for Families

Families traveling to Montauk will find a welcoming array of hotels geared toward making stays comfortable for guests of all ages. These family-friendly hotels in Montauk not only offer spacious accommodations but also boast amenities that cater to both parents and children, such as kids' clubs, family pools, and activities designed to engage younger guests. With close proximity to beaches, parks, and Montauk's charming town center, these establishments ensure that families have easy access to the best attractions. The emphasis here is on creating unforgettable experiences for families, making these hotels ideal bases from which to explore all that Montauk has to offer.

View all photos

8.7
Excellent
1827 Reviews

Montauk Manor Hotel

📍 236 Edgemere Street

From 174$

Perched atop a hill with sweeping views of the Montauk landscape, Montauk Manor offers a blend of historical grandeur and modern luxury. This majestic property, with its Tudor-style architecture, embodies elegance and sophistication. Guests can choose from a variety of accommodations, each rich in comfort and style, making it a perfect retreat for those looking to indulge in luxury while soaking in the rich history of Montauk. The Manor features a range of amenities, including a spa, indoor and outdoor pools, and tennis courts, ensuring a stay that is as relaxing as it is luxurious. With its distinctive charm and unparalleled service, Montauk Manor stands out as a prime destination for travelers in search of luxury accommodations in Montauk.
Check Availability
Add to compare

View all photos

8.6
Excellent
1217 Reviews

Montauk Blue Hotel

📍 108 South Emerson Avenue

From 215$

Located right on the beachfront, Montauk Blue Hotel is a favorite among families looking for comfort and convenience. The hotel offers a variety of room options, including spacious suites with kitchenettes, perfect for those family meals and snacks. With its direct access to the sandy shores of Montauk and a heated indoor pool, families can enjoy both beach activities and on-site relaxation. The hotel's friendly staff are always on hand to recommend family-friendly dining and attractions, ensuring your family's stay in Montauk is as enjoyable as it is comfortable.
Check Availability
Add to compare

Location